The Most Popular Engagement Rings from Croft & Stern in 2025
When couples walk through the doors at Croft & Stern Jewelry Designs looking for an engagement ring, they’re not just shopping — they’re choosing something meant to last, that tells their unique story. These four rings stood out as the top picks of 2025 for their style, balance, and craftsmanship.
A Shift Toward Non-Traditional Three-Stone Rings
One clear shift we saw in 2025 was a move away from perfectly matched three-stone rings. Clients leaned into non-traditional compositions—fancy-shape diamonds, intentional gaps in size ratios, and side stones that didn’t try to compete with the center. The objective stayed the same as it always has: pull focus to the center stone, but do it with more personality and contrast. Design-wise, we saw two clear directions emerge. Either dainty, refined bands meant to layer with multiple wedding bands over time, or one-and-done statement rings that stand on their own with no need for stacking. Different approaches, same mindset: thoughtful design that feels personal, not prescribed.
1. Aurora — Classic Brilliance With Timeless Appeal
Price-wise, Aurora is one of the most versatile designs — simple yet refined. It’s a 6-prong engagement ring built around a round brilliant center (diamond sold separately), with two small earth-mined accent diamonds adding subtle sparkle.
What makes Aurora great is its balance of tradition and everyday wearability. It doesn’t shout, but it always looks right — whether you’re out for date night or for a Sunday walk. Its design is rooted in what engagement rings have done for over a century: show off the center gem with class and structure.
2. Tempting — For the Someone Who Wants a Statement
If you’re not afraid to go a bit bigger and bolder, Tempting earns its name. This ring is meant to show off — featuring a design often built around a 3 or 4.00 ct center stone (sold separately) with 40 additional round brilliant diamonds in a European-style shank that floods the setting with light.
This is the ring for someone who appreciates high-impact sparkle with a traditional yet authoritative feel. It’s a modern and sturdy ring, with a feminine style.
3. Juno — Elegant and Thoughtful
Juno takes a slightly softer and more artistic route. Designed with 0.26 ctw pear-shaped earth-mined diamonds flanking a 1.25 ct center stone (sold separately), it pairs the old-world appeal of yellow gold with a smart faux-bezel look that feels current but timeless.
This is a ring that quietly impresses. It keeps a classic backbone while offering just enough detail to feel special and intentional. Switch out your future wedding bands and watch this ring transform.
4. Marigold — Bold Center, Refined Surround
For those who love substance without sacrificing elegance, Marigold brings the goods. Its 2.50 ct cushion cut center stone (sold separately) takes center stage, held in double prongs and balanced with two marquise earth-mined diamonds for accent.
This piece hits a sweet spot: vintage-inspired accents meet a strong, modern centerpiece. It’s not flashy for flash’s sake — it’s about proportion and presence.
Conclusion: Tradition With Modern Purpose
All four rings reflect what Croft & Stern has built its reputation on — well-crafted jewelry that honors tradition and serves people who are thoughtful about what a ring really means. If you’re choosing a lifetime commitment piece, these rings are worth seeing in person.
Whether you lean toward classic light sparkle, big bold brilliance, elegant artistic detail, or substantial center presence, there’s a standout here — and every one can be customized to fit your style and story.
Schedule your unique engagement ring appointment with the calendar below. We look forward to making you sparkle!
